Quick Links
Tired of password breaches, I ditched my manager and tried creating my own secure passwords. It was a disaster. DIY methods failed me, and I returned to a password manager for peace of mind.
The DIY Methods I Tried
When I set out tocreate my own secure passwords, I knew I needed a system that balanced strength and memorability. After all, a password is only as good as your ability to recall it.
First, I tried the passphrase method, where you string together random words to create a long but easy-to-remember password. Instead of purely random words, I added a personal twist—mixing in childhood references, favorite books, and inside jokes. This worked well at first. A passphrase like “LemonTornadoAstro1997!” felt secure yet familiar. But the more accounts I needed passwords for, the harder it became to remember which passphrase I had assigned to which site.
Next, I testedthe Diceware password creation method, where you roll physical dice to select words from a predefined list. This approach is completely random and highly secure. But it was a nightmare in practice. Rolling dice, looking up words, and writing them down felt like cracking a secret code for every single account. Worse, memorizing these random words proved far harder than my customized passphrases. I could handle a few, but once I hit a dozen, my recall started failing.
Should You Keep Changing Your Password? 5 Password Security Myths Busted
Unfortunately, some of the best-known password advice will make your accounts insecure.
Finally, I experimented with a mental algorithm, a structured way to generate passwords based on site names. For example, I could take the first three letters of the site, add a special character, and append a memorable number sequence. So, “Amazon” might become “Ama#2023!” At first, this was the easiest method to recall. But security-wise, it had a fatal flaw: patterns are predictable, and predictable passwords are weak. If one password leaks, a hacker could guess the others.
While these methods all had strengths, I quickly saw their breaking points. My memory had limits, and managing passwords across dozens of accounts became overwhelming. Worse, every workaround I tried to make things easier weakened security, defeating the whole purpose.
Why I Went Back to a Password Manager
After struggling with DIY methods, I finally admitted defeat. The reality was simple: password managers solved every problem I was trying to fix on my own.
Password managers generate truly random passwords, eliminating the need for me to think up clever passphrases. Instead of agonizing over security trade-offs, I could let the manager create a unique, high-entropy password for every site.
Second, they store and autofill passwords, so I no longer had to memorize or manually type them in. This instantly removed the frustration of forgotten logins, password resets, and annoying character restrictions. Even for sites with weird rules, my password manager adapted, saving each variation automatically.
Password managers also come packed with security features. Many offer two-factor authentication (2FA) for added protection, analyze password strength to flag weak or reused ones, and alert you if your data appears in a breach. These gave me peace of mind, knowing my accounts were as secure as possible.
What Is the Safest Password Manager to Use?
Looking to keep your login credentials secure? You need to know the safest password managers for Windows, Mac, iOS, Android, and more.
Most importantly, they scale effortlessly. Whether I had 10 accounts or 200, the experience remained the same. There was no more mental clutter, no more anxiety about whether I was using a strong password. It was all handled for me.
For anyone struggling with password security, I highly recommend using a password manager likeNordPass. It offers secure password generation, encrypted storage, and breach monitoring to keep your accounts safe. Othergreat password managersincludeProtonPassand1Password.
My DIY password experiment taught me a hard truth: sometimes, letting go is the best way to take control. Creating my own passwords felt empowering at first, but the mental strain, inconsistent website rules, and sheer number of accounts made it unsustainable. A password manager made my digital life simpler, safer, and stress-free.
