The cast ofSupernaturalhas contributed to the show’s popularity over the years,as each episode introduces a bunch of new characters that Sam and Dean Winchester must investigate. With Jensen Ackles, Jared Padalecki, and Misha Collins becoming most known in their acting careers for forming the main part ofSupernatural’scastfor over a decade, it is not surprising that other actors have risen to fame for simply appearing on the show. For example,Alden Ehrenreich’s first role was inSupernaturalseason 1, before he appeared inSolo: A Star Wars Storyin 2018.
Over the years, several members of theSupernaturalcast have ventured into other films, TV shows, and even voice acting, showcasing their versatility and range. Additionally, there are plenty of instances where the fantasy show’s cast appear on-screen together outside the series, most notably inThe Boys. While itmay have highlighted certain actors and cemented their reputations,some of theSupernaturalcast’s best roles lie outside the award-winning show, in other movies and TV shows released before, during, and after theirSupernaturalappearances.
10Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania (2023)
Starring: Kathryn Newton
FollowingKathryn Newton’s breakout role onSupernatural, the actor has since moved onto blockbuster movies likeAnt-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania.Kathryn Newton first appeared inSupernaturalas a young Claire Novak, the daughter of Castiel’s vessel, Jimmy Novak. Claire proved herself to be a strong and capable hunter as she grew up, and her stubborn nature provided similarities with Dean Winchester.
Paul Rudd’s Advice Pushed Kathryn Newton To Tackle Lisa Frankenstein
Exclusive: Paul Rudd’s acting advice inspired Kathryn Newton to take on Lisa Frankenstein and could be the key to Cassie Lang’s future arc.
However, Newton has since starred in Marvel’sAnt-Man and the Wasp: Quantumaniaas Cassie Lang, the daughter of Scott Lang (Paul Rudd). The Marvel Cinematic Universe movie followed Scott Lang, Hope Van Dyne, and their family as they are suddenly transported to the Quantum Realm. While trapped there, the group must face the prolific villain, Kang the Conqueror (played by Jonathan Majors).Kathryn Newton’s humor and emotional depth made Cassie Lang a standout character, demonstrating theSupernaturalactor’stransition into blockbuster films.
9Watchmen (2009)
Starring: Jeffrey Dean Morgan, Matt Frewer
Based on the DC Comics limited series of the same name,Watchmensees a group of retired superheroes investigating another superhero’s murder and uncovering a grand conspiracy which connects them all.Watchmenis reminiscent ofThe Boysdue to its dystopian anti-superhero genre, and the movie had favorable reviews, with a 71% Popcornmeter on Rotten Tomatoes. The Zack Snyder movie starsSupernatural’sJeffrey Dean Morgan and Matt Frewer in supporting roles.
Jeffrey Dean Morgan made his mark onSupernaturalfor his portrayal of the monster-obsessed head of the Winchester family, John Winchester
Jeffrey Dean Morgan made his mark onSupernaturalfor his portrayal of the monster-obsessed head of the Winchester family, John Winchester, despite only appearing in 12 episodes of the monster hunting show. Matt Frewer had an even smaller role inSupernatural, only appearing in two episodes, but his role as Pestilence (one of the Four Horsemen) demanded a bigger presence.Watchmenoffers both Jeffrey Dean Morgan and Matt Frewer interesting roles, which really reimburse the movie’s themes.
8Ten Inch Hero (2007)
Starring: Jensen Ackles and Danneel Ackles
As one of the main cast ofSupernatural, it is somewhat surprising that Jensen Ackles found time to star as a main character in a dramedy movie alongside his recurring role as Dean Winchester. However, this is exactly what happened in 2007 when Jensen Ackles starred inTen Inch Hero. The movie follows the lives of a group of people that work in a sandwich shop, who each have their own distinctive personalities, andJensen Ackles plays a crazy-haired alternative guy called Priestly.
Danneel Ackles has appeared in five episodes ofSupernaturalsince 2013and also served as a producer for the spinoff series,The Winchesters.
The character really stands out in thismovie as Jensen Ackles delivers his bestperformance in making his character extremely likable, despite his odd appearance.Priestly offers a completely different role to Dean Winchester, showcasing Jensen Ackles’ range. Furthermore, Ackles is joined by a laterSupernaturalco-star, Danneel Ackles, who he married in 2010 after meeting duringTen Inch Hero.
7Walker (2021-2024)
Starring: Jared Padalecki, Genevieve Padalecki, Jensen Ackles, Colin Ford, Mitch Pileggi, and Jake Abel
Jared Padalecki rose to fame due to his role as the milder-mannered Winchester brother, Sam Winchester, onSupernatural. However,in his first role sinceSupernatural’sseason 15 ending in 2020, Jared Padalecki joined the CW reboot seriesWalkerin 2021. Padalecki plays Cordell Walker, a character that must wrestle with family drama and reconnect with his children while he investigates the suspicious death of his wife, offering a more rugged role for the actor.
Colin Ford has played two younger versions of Jared Padalecki: Sam Winchester inSupernaturaland Cordell Walker inWalker.
Interestingly,Walkerhas had manySupernaturalcast appear on the show, from Genevieve Padalecki (Ruby) to Colin Ford (Young Sam Winchester). Jared Padalecki’sSupernaturalco-star Jensen Ackles has even directed and featured in one episode ofWalker, showcasing the cast’s tight bond on and off-screen. With a 91% Popcornmeter, the show has been well-loved by fans, but its viewership dwindling led toWalkerseason 5’scancelation in May 2024. Nevertheless,the show offers the perfect story for those who liked the family drama aspect ofSupernatural.
Starring: Jeffrey Dean Morgan, Lauren Cohan, and Aldis Hodge
The Walking Deadspanned 11 seasons and has been praised for its take on the zombie genre, earning multiple awards throughout its run, including two Primetime Emmy Awards.The show has featured three actors fromSupernatural’scast: Jeffrey Dean Morgan, Lauren Cohan, and Aldis Hodge. While Jeffrey Dean Morgan and Lauren Cohan star in big roles on the hit zombie TV series, Aldis Hodge only appeared in one episode, similarly to his minor appearance inSupernaturalas the Special Child, Jake.
Jensen Ackles Proposed The Walking Dead Role Would Give Him 2 Big Supernatural Reunions
Jensen Ackles addressed the possibility of joining The Walking Dead earlier in 2024, and his role could give him two huge Supernatural reunions.
Lauren Cohan delivered a fantastic performance inThe Walking Dead, however, it was Jeffrey Dean Morgan’s Negan that stole the show following his introduction in 2016.His charismatic personality and iconic barbed wire baseball bat made Negan a fan favorite onThe Walking Dead, showcasingJeffrey Dean Morgan’s skill in what is arguably his best TV role. Negan’s bat was so memorable for the show and in popular culture thatSupernaturalactually included a reference to it in season 12, episode 15, “Somewhere Between Heaven and Hell.”
5Arrow (2012-2020)
Starring: Alexander Calvert, Katie Cassidy, Briana Buckmaster, Osric Chau, Ty Olsson, and Madison McLaughlin
Arrowis another CW show which often features members ofSupernatural’scast, and there is a long list of actors that have appeared in both, making it a highly connected show.Supernaturalstars such as Alexander Calvert and Madison McLaughlin both had story arcs onArrow, featuring in a number of episodes as Lonnie Machin/Anarky and Evelyn Sharp/Artemis. Ruby actor Katie Cassidy had a much larger role onArrow, however, appearing in 152 episodes as Laurel Lance (or Black Siren).
Katie Cassidy was the first person to play the demon Ruby inSupernatural. The second was Genevieve Padalecki.
Despite only appearing in six episodes of the fantasy show, Katie Cassidy was the first iteration of the demon Ruby to appear onSupernatural, making her a memorable part of the cast. Yet, following her role onSupernatural,Katie Cassidy’s talents truly shone inArrowas she utilized the physical skills learned from playing Rubyin her superhero character. Cassidy’s performance as Laurel grew better each season, and she ended up being one of thebest characters in the Arrowverse by the show’send.
4The Boys (2019-Present)
Starring: Jensen Ackles, Jim Beaver, Jeffrey Dean Morgan, Robert Benedict, and Gattlin Griffith
As the original showrunner and creator ofSupernatural, Eric Kripke made a name for himself through the hit fantasy series. After departing the show following season 5’s finale, Kripke moved onto other projects, including Amazon Prime’sThe Boys.Therefore, it comes as no surprise thatsome ofSupernatural’scast have appeared in the showrunner’s new TV series, especially due to its impressive 93% Tomatometer on Rotten Tomatoes.
The Boys’ Best Change To The Comic Book Made The Prime Video Show So Much Better And Became Obvious In Season 4
Jensen Ackles' Soldier Boy character change was good for Amazon’s The Boys because the comic character was much weaker and wouldn’t fit the show.
There is a growing list ofSupernaturalactors that show up inThe Boys, and each have their own defining roles which deliver something special to the show, often in complete contrast to their character in Kripke’s previous project. Jim Beaver plays a corporate role surprisingly well, considering hisSupernaturalcharacter had a vendetta against billionaire businessman Dick Roman, and Jensen Ackles quickly became a fan favorite as the arrogant supe, Soldier Boy. Jeffrey Dean Morgan andRob Benedict also joined the cast inThe Boysseason 4, with Benedict delivering a certainly unforgettable performance forSupernaturalfans.
3Doom Patrol (2019-2023)
Starring: Mark Sheppard, Curtis Armstrong, Julie McNiven, Julian Richings, and Ruth Connell
FromSupernatural’sJeremy Carver, came the DC reimagined seriesDoom Patrol.Mark Sheppard, along with a few other members of theSupernaturalcast, starred in the comic book series, and his character, Willoughby Kipling, was a great addition to the show. ThroughoutDoom Patrol, the magician Kipling helps the outcast superheroes in their adventures, and this, coupled with his blunt and carefree personality, made Mark Sheppard’s character likablein the show.
Doom Patrolis a unique show due to its weirdness, but its deep character development and subtle blend of dark comedy and offbeat superhero genre make it a brilliant watch
Mark Sheppard has a similar role inSupernatural, as Crowley, a crossroad demon who eventually becomes an ally for the Winchesters in later seasons.Crowley’s charming nature and schemes against Team Free Will made him a fan favorite onSupernatural, and this translates well into hisDoom Patrolcharacter.Doom Patrolis a unique show due to its weirdness, but its deep character development and subtle blend of dark comedy and offbeat superhero genre make it a brilliant watch, especially with theSupernaturalcast’s appearances.
2Deadwood (2004-2006)
Starring: Jim Beaver, Titus Welliver, and Timothy Omundson
Deadwoodis an American Western TV show set in the 1870s, following the growth of the town of Deadwood, South Dakota, during the Gold Rush. The series features historical figures like Wild Bill Hickok and Al Swearengen, but also features a fewSupernaturalactors. Jim Beaver plays the role of Ellsworth, a kind-hearted but tough miner who becomes entangled in the town’s struggles.
All 3 Deadwood Seasons (& The Sequel Movie) Ranked Worst To Best
Deadwood and its sequel Deadwood: The Movie are considered peak Prestige TV, but that doesn’t mean that some seasons aren’t better than others.
Beaver’s portrayal stands out due to his ability to add depth to a moral character in a corrupt world. InSupernatural, Beaver played a similar role as Bobby Singer, a lonely man who acts as a father figure to Sam and Dean Winchester, while simultaneously upholding his reputation as one of the best and most knowledgeable hunters around, making his death one of thesaddest character deaths inSupernatural.Jim Beaver’s role inDeadwoodsimilarly makes Ellsworth a key emotional anchor in the series, and Titus Welliver (who played War) and Timothy Omundson (who played Cain) also feature in the show.
1Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. (2013-2020)
Following her short role onSupernatural, Adrianne Palicki joined the cast ofAgents of S.H.I.E.L.D., a Marvel Cinematic Universe spinoff show set around Agent Phil Coulson and his team as they tackle various threats, conspiracies, and global dangers.Adrianne Palicki played Bobbi Morse (Mockingbird) in the series, a highly skilled field agent and expert fighter, a far cry from her ratherunderutilized character Jessica Moore inSupernatural.
Palicki’s ability to go from a mild-mannered college student inSupernatural,to a fully-fledged leader of a government agency inAgents of S.H.I.E.L.D.,showcases her dynamic range as an actor
While Bobbi only had a small role on the show, 12 out of 136 total episodes,Palicki’s character’s presence was felt largely due to her competence as an agent. Palicki’s ability to go from a mild-mannered college student inSupernatural,to a fully-fledged leader of a government agency inAgents of S.H.I.E.L.D.,showcases her dynamic range as an actor. Furthermore, considering the Marvel series has an overwhelmingly positive 95% Tomatometer and 91% Popcornmeter, there was no better series for theSupernaturalactor to appear in.
Supernatural
Cast
Supernatural is a television series that follows brothers Sam and Dean Winchester, who were raised by their father to hunt and combat supernatural entities after losing their mother to a demonic force. Traversing the American landscape in their ‘67 Chevy Impala, they face numerous paranormal threats.
